My Chinese educated retiree friends on their return from holidaying in China often enthused about the benefits the retirees there enjoy.
For example, they learned that retirees either pay a subsidized rate or free travel on public buses throughout the day. “In Singapore, our retirees above 60 pay subsidized rates only outside peak hours,” they fumed.
And they also pointed out that many Chinese retirees get a pension of 1500 yuan which is quite substantial.
So on a recent visit to Shanghai, a resident asked me about our CPF scheme.In turn I asked him how much Shanghai retirees got from their government.
He said that it ranged from US 500 to US 5000. I was incredulous and asked him to repeat the figures.
Making a sweep of his hand, he said, “See all these elderly people here in the park? They are enjoying their golden years, playing mahjong, dancing, singing, flying kites, fishing, in the park. Do your elderly enjoy life like this?”
I sighed and said, “Most of them still have to slog.”
It depended on a person’s last job but the least was US 500. The higher a person’s salary before retirement, the higher his pension the Shanghainese explained.
Who qualified for the US 5000 pension I asked. He replied” “War veterans”.
I asked him, “Do employees need to make any contributions during their working life.”
He replied, “No, the pension money comes from the employer and the government.”
China has the world’s latest ageing population. More than 185 mullions Chunese were 60 or older by the end of 2011, according to the Ministry of Civil Affairs.
Although verification is needed on this subject, the escapable impression is that, say what you will about the Chinese government, in China the elderly are taken better care of than in Singapore.
A PAP Minister even suggested sending our elderly to nursing home in JB where costs are lower!
In contrast, the Chinese government has decided that most of its elderly population should grow old at home and have sufficient care services.
There are thousands of elderly poor in Singapore struggling with the high cost of utilities, medical treatment, transport and daily necessities. But the government balk at giving generous help out of fear it will foster a crutch mentality or, worse, usher in an era of welfarism.
In Beijing, all residents above 80 get coupons worth 100 yuan a month to subsidise daily necessities or services including haircuts and hiring domestic help.
It’s the toil and sweat and sacrifices of your parents, now mostly in their 60s to 80s, who largely laid the foundations of modern Singapore, it must always be remembered.
But the PAP government would rather vote themselves million-dollar salaries than spend on the elderly.
Shame on them! Great, great shame!
Below: China’s elderly enjoying their golden years
Singapore’s elderly: still slogging away, a common sight
Malaysia: young cleaner